ReadyMadeApps
Best Apps to Enhance a Shopify Store Already Set Up — A Category-by-Category Guide
Not a random list — a prioritized order for which app category to tackle next, based on what actually moves the needle first.
Quick Answer: The best apps to enhance an already set up Shopify store, in priority order, are abandoned cart recovery and reviews first (highest immediate return), checkout upsells second, then SMS/loyalty tools once the fundamentals are proven working — not a random grab-bag of everything at once. This exact question comes up on Reddit's Shopify forums constantly, usually met with overwhelming, unordered app lists. Here's the prioritized version.
Reddit's Shopify forums answer this question with long, unordered lists that leave beginners unsure where to actually start. I want to give you a genuine priority order — which category to tackle first, second, and third — based on what actually returns value fastest.
Tier One — Cart Recovery and Reviews
Key Takeaway: These two recover revenue and build trust on traffic you already have — the fastest return of any category.
Abandoned cart recovery and review collection both work on traffic you're already generating, meaning no additional marketing spend required to see their benefit. This is why they belong first — covered in full in our product review apps guide and recommended apps guide.
Tier Two — Checkout Upsells
Key Takeaway: Increases average order value on the same traffic — the next highest-leverage addition once tier one is confirmed working.
Once cart recovery and reviews are confirmed running properly, a checkout upsell app is the natural next addition — it increases average order value without requiring any new traffic. Add this only after verifying tier one is genuinely working, not simultaneously.
| Tier | Category | Why This Order |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cart recovery + reviews | Works on existing traffic, no new spend |
| 2 | Checkout upsells | Increases value on same traffic |
| 3 | SMS / loyalty | Needs proven repeat-purchase base first |
Tier Three — SMS Marketing and Loyalty Programs
Key Takeaway: These work best once you have a proven base of repeat customers — adding them too early produces limited data to act on.
SMS marketing and loyalty programs depend on having enough repeat customers to actually generate meaningful data. Adding these before your store has a proven repeat-purchase pattern means limited signal to optimize against — better to wait until tiers one and two have produced real traction first.
Shopify Plugins — Confirming What's Actually Installed vs. Active
Key Takeaway: An installed plugin isn't the same as an active, configured one — audit your current plugins before adding anything new.
Before adding new apps in any tier, audit what's already installed. It's common for stores to accumulate installed Shopify plugins that were never fully configured or have since been forgotten, quietly costing monthly fees while doing nothing. Clean this up before layering on anything new.
Want tier one already configured? Browse EcomChief's catalog.
Tier One Already Configured, Ready for Tier Two
Key Takeaway: Cart recovery and reviews verified working — start adding from tier two forward.
The stores in EcomChief's catalog are built using the exact method described in this post. Not templated. Not assembled from a page builder. Custom sections, locked design systems, production-ready — the same standard I hold my own theme to. Every store starts at $99, with an optional $148 traffic package if you want marketing support from day one. If you want to own a store built this way without spending months developing the method yourself, this is where to start.
The Bottom Line
Key Takeaway: Cart recovery and reviews first, upsells second, SMS/loyalty third — a real priority order, not a random list.
Prioritize apps in tiers, not all at once. Cart recovery and reviews first, since they work on existing traffic. Checkout upsells next. SMS and loyalty programs only once you have a proven repeat-customer base to act on. Audit what's already installed before adding anything new.
Helpful EcomChief Resources
Key Takeaway: Quick links to browse, optimize, and get answers.
Here are useful links:
- Browse All Businesses — From $99
- What's Included
- Talk to Us Before You Buy
- Product Review Apps
- Recommended Apps for Dropshipping Automation
- Full Optimization Checklist
Ready to start with tier one already handled? Browse the catalog.
Related reading
All articles
Free Online Business Calculators
Estimate costs, profits, ROI, affiliate earnings, and business value before you spend money.